our storeCarmack’s has one of the largest selections of premium cigars in the Midwest with some of the best prices. Our huge selection includes all your favorites like Padron Anniversary, Opus X, Don Pepin Garcia, Tatuaje, C.A.O., Rocky Patel, Casa Magna, Kristoff, Acid, La Flor Dominicana and many, many more to choose from (click here to view our listing of cigars). Carmack’s also has a large selection of cigar accessories and stocks more than 50 cigar humidors at the lowest prices.

Carmack’s also has a large selection of premium pipes and over 60 pipe tobaccos for your smoking pleasure. Pipes like Peterson, Nording, Savinelli, and Paronelli to name a few.

Store Highlights

  • 28-foot walk-in humidor
  • 40 feet of cigar filled humidor cabinets
  • 3 cabinets of Arturo Fuente cigars
  • Entire cabinet of Padron cigars
  • Large selection of pipes & tobacco
  • 39 Private cigar lockers available for rent annually
  • Humidors - 50 different styles
  • Cigar and pipe accessories
  • Cigar lounge with 73-inch plasma HDTV
  • 3 additional flat screen TV's
  • 18 high back leather chairs
  • POKER LOUNGE seating area with 10-seat poker table
    • 10 high back leather chairs
    • Bar Fireplace and 50- inch Plasma
  • Free Wi-Fi

shop and lounge

Our Lounge

We offer two lounges for your smoking pleasure with 18 high back leather chairs in one room and 10 high back leather chairs in the other room.  We have a 73-inch plasma HDTV and a 50-in plasma HDTV where you can watch different shows (NetFlix) as well as sports and will sometimes have pay per view events that are offered.  Throughout the shop is free Wi-Fi which you connect your laptop, tablet or smartphone and surf the internet, check e-mail or have a video conference call.

It is our goal to create an inviting and wonderful atmosphere and experience for all our customers who come to the shop.  There is no membership fee to smoke in our lounge, however, please note that our shop and lounge is for folks who buy our cigars, pipes, and accessories.  If you bring any cigars that are not purchased from Carmack's, you will be assessed a $5 cut fee for each cigar.  This helps us defray additional costs and keeps our prices for our products very low and reasonable for you, our valued customer.

As our guest in our lounge, we expect you to use common courtesy and respect for all customers. Any form of disrespect to the shop or to any individual will not be tolerated and you may be asked to leave the shop if you fail to adhere to this policy.


We currently have 39 lockers in our shop for rent (36 small lockers and 3 large lockers).  The annual rental fee for small lockers is $100 and the annual rental fee for large lockers is $125. Rent is due upon commencement of the annual contract which begins September 1st of every year.  You will receive a key to your locker as well as a nameplate.  After one year you will have the option of renewing your locker or giving up your locker to folks on our waiting list.  

If you'd like to rent a locker from us, please click here and fill out our online locker rental request form indicating what locker type you are interested in and we will notify you as to the availability of the locker or place you on our waiting list.

Indy A-List Vote for Carmack's Today!

a list button

Upcoming Events!

June 10, 2017
Rocky Patel
12pm - 4pm
Click here for details!

July, 2017
12pm - 4pm
Click here for details

Download the Cigar Dojo App

This app notifies you of upcoming events including events at Carmack's Cigar Shop, where to smoke, reviews and pictures of cigar smokers!

cigar dojo

Carmack's Twitter Feed

carmackscigars Come to Our Padr�n and Pipes Event at Carmack's, Saturday, Dec 23, 2017! https://t.co/aE2aFpoOHq https://t.co/R6dCGOyDBB
carmackscigars Always take note of who supports you genuinely. Those are the people you should always keep… https://t.co/QzVF5R33i1
carmackscigars Today is the Day 9a-4p It's Another Awesome Event at Carmacks: Arturo Fuente Cigar Event! https://t.co/LAy9kHmAso https://t.co/rVt0SR3JDH
carmackscigars It's Black Friday! But Tomorrow is Fuente Day at Carmack's Cigar Shop! https://t.co/CZ5Mp7s28w https://t.co/MaF7aehHSN
carmackscigars Think Turkey, then Think Cigars - Come to Our Arturo Fuente Cigar Event Sat, Nov 25! https://t.co/7MYLSFRTbp https://t.co/0ooXWbScnv
carmackscigars Reminder: Come to Our Arturo Fuente Cigar Event this Saturday, November 25! https://t.co/eBMqNL7Cpm https://t.co/Er8NOI3IwX

Carmack's Facebook Feed

Carmack's Newsletter Signup

Go to top