NEW: Alleyway pickup! Call the shop (317.773.3770) place your order, then stay in your car and pick up in the alley behind the shop! Click here for more.
Per Indiana State law, must be 21 to enter.
Alleyway Pick-Up!
Now offering Alleyway and Curbside Pick-Up!
Call the shop before you arrive at 317.773.3770 so we can get your order ready!
Cash, credit, or debit!
Stay for a Drink
We obtained our liquor license in 2021 and offer a great selection of bourbons, beer, and other favorites - adding new tastes regularly.
Hang out in our lounge with us!
Follow Us on Socials
We post new additions to our bar, special order cigars, and info about events - plus drink and cigar pairings frequently!
Follow us to get the most updated info about what's going on at the shop.
Parking Info
Weekdays from 8am until 5pm - 2 hour max parking on the square, plus hourly parking in the garages and metered parking right behind the shop.
Free parking everywhere after 5pm on weekdays and all day on weekends.
Matthew S.
“Carmack's is such a cool place. They taught me how to navigate the sticks I think my pallet wants, and are always happy to make suggestions or answer questions. I highly recommend checking this place out!"
Terrance P.
"Great experience!! I called around to get a specific cigar that nobody had. These guys had them and ordered a box just for me, and even stored it in their humidor for a few extra days since it was a gift. All around great transaction!"
Nick T.
“Good selection of pipe tobacco - premium types I can usually only find online.”