Welcome to Carmack's Cigar Shop

home pageWe offer one of the largest selections of premium cigars in the Midwest, servicing all of Noblesville, Indianapolis, Fishers, Geist, Zionsville, Carmel, Westfield, Hamilton County and Marion County with some of best prices! We also stock a great inventory of pipes and tobaccos as well as cigar accessories including lighters, cutters, ashtrays and humidors.  Just located on the square in downtown Noblesville, Indiana, we invite you to come into our shop and experience a great cigar or two!  Bring your friends and stay for awhile, relax, enjoy a cigar in our lounge or watch a movie or game on one of our big screen TV's or get on the internet with our free Wi-Fi available for you.  All in all, it's about having a memorable  experience with good friends and great cigars.

See you soon and stay smoky!

Your friends at Carmack's Cigar Shop!


Fuente Anejo, Rocky 20th Edge, and EP Carillo L.E. Lonsdale just arrived. And more goodies comin. Don’t miss the My Father Don Pepin event this Saturday 12-17-22, from 12-4pm.

42EEA564 59C708AE 49700D6B

Introducing Curbside Delivery!

We will cater to you as we now offer Carmack's Curbside Delivery!  Just call us at 317.773.3770 and tell us your order.  Then stop by the shop in the back alley by the awning and call us and we'll come out to your car and deliver your cigars and charge your card.  It's that simple!



This is a new cigar created in partnership with Guy Fieri and Espinosa Cigars.  Great taste and flavor profile and we've got it here at Carmack's!  Stop by and grab a couple of sticks and enjoy!





tatuaje advent calendarsTatuaje 2021 and 2022 Advent Calendars are Now Here!

Limited stock and rare - these will be going fast! Get yours today!

The Tatuaje 2021 Advent Calendar, which is also referred to as the green version for the color of the stripe along the bottom of the box and the color of the shirt that Tatuaje’s Pete Johnson wears on the front of the box, was slated to have been released last year, but delays in the production of the packaging forced it to be pushed into 2022. When Johnson announced the delay in October 2022, he said that it would eventually ship alongside the 2022 edition, also known as the blue version.

We now have both 2021 and 2022 Advent Calendars in stock at Carmack's!

As for what it is in Tatuaje’s 2021 Advent Calendar, it is a total of 24 cigars, all of which measure 4 1/2 x 46. The core lines of Tatuaje and L’Atelier Imports make up 15 of the 24 cigars, with the following lines included:

Cabaiguan, Cabaiguan Guapos Natural, El Triunfador, Fausto
L’Atelier, La Mission, Négociant, Surrogates Tramp Stamp, Tatuaje Black Label, Tatuaje Brown Label, Tatuaje Havana VI, Tatuaje ME II, Tatuaje Nuevitas Jibaro, Tatuaje Tattoo, Tatuaje Verocú

As for the other nine cigars, five of them will be 4 1/2 x 46 versions of Monster Series releases, two will be holiday-themed cigars, one is described as a “Limited,” and the final cigar will be a Tatuaje Pumpkin, the company’s Halloween-themed cigars. The five Monster Series releases will be the same in all of the 2021 Advent Calendars.

When it comes to what’s in the 2022 Advent Calendar, the sizes remain the same but Johnson isn’t disclosing what actual cigars will be included, however, there will only be seven repeat cigars from the 2021 Advent Calendar, and the five Monster Series cigars, the two holiday cigars, and the Pumpkin cigar will all be different.

“The Advents are supposed to be a secret of what is behind each door so I prefer not to go into details of the exact cigars in each calendar,” Johnson said when asked what was inside the 2022 version.

We have a limited supply of these Advent Calendars available at $200/each and we have only ten 2021 calendars and ten 2022 calendars so supply is limited!
Please contact the shop for availability and pricing at (317) 773-3770 and get yours today!






home cigarlisting

Our Cigars

View our incredible selection of premium cigars from mild, medium to full-bodied. Step in our 28-foot humidor or browse over 40 feet of humidor cabinets stocked with cigars!

homepage events cta

Our Events

Our next awesome event:
Padrón and Pipes Cigar Event
Saturday, December 18 from 11am - 5pm
Click here for details

home cometotheshop

Come to Our Shop

822 Logan St.
Noblesville, IN 46060

Store Hours
Monday - Friday: 10am - 7pm
Saturday: 9am - 6pm
Sunday: 12pm - 4pm

"Carmack's Cigar Shop is by far one of the best cigar shops in Indiana! From their extensive inventory of cigars at fair prices to the comfortable lounge area and friendly atmosphere, it is an oasis of cigars for the new and aficiando smoker! Whether you just want a great smoke or want to relax the lounge, watch a game or attend an event with some of the most fascinating cigar producers, you'll want to visit soon! Carmacks is the place to be." ~ M. Plumer

"This is the hands-down the best cigar shop in Indiana. They will take care of you like family love this place..." ~ T. Atkins

"Such a neat shop. First time in today and everyone there was very welcoming! I'll definitely be going back :)" ~ S. Wicker


Carmack's Cigar Shop selected for 2020 Noblesville Small Business Excellence Award Noblesville,IN - 10/26/2020

Carmack's Cigar Shop has been selected for the 2020 Noblesville Small Business Excellence Award in the Tobacco Shops classification by the Noblesville Small Business Excellence Award Program. Various sources of information were gathered and analyzed to choose the winners in each category. The 2020 Noblesville Small Business Excellence Award Program focuses on quality, not quantity. Winners are determined based on the information gathered both internally by the Noblesville Small Business Excellence Award Program and data provided by third parties. About the Noblesville Small Business Excellence Awards Program The Noblesville Small Business Excellence Awards recognizes outstanding small businesses that serve the Noblesville area. Each year, our selection committee identifies businesses that we believe have achieved outstanding marketing success in their local community and business classification.

Recognition is given to those companies that have shown the ability to use their best practices and implemented programs to generate competitive advantages and long-term value. These are small businesses that enhance the positive image of small business through service to their customers and our community. These exceptional companies help make the Noblesville area a vibrant and vital place to live. The Noblesville Small Business Excellence Awards was established to reward the best of small businesses in Noblesville. Our organization works exclusively with local business owners, trade groups, professional associations and other business advertising and marketing groups. Our mission is to award the small business community’s contributions to the U.S. economy.

Carmack's Twitter Feed

Carmack's Facebook Feed

Carmack's Newsletter Signup

Go to top