store frontCarmack’s Cigar and Tobacco Shop was established in 1998 by owners Dave and Jeff Carmack (father and son). The first shop opened in downtown Indianapolis inside the Hyatt Regency Hotel. After four years in the Hyatt, they wanted to expand their selection and space so they closed the downtown store and opened a 3000-square-foot shop in beautiful, historic downtown Noblesville, IN. With 5 flat screen televisions, poker table, fireplace, and plenty of leather chairs for your smoking pleasure, Carmack’s welcomes everyone from the novice to the true cigar aficionado.

Dave and Jeff Carmack grew up in Anderson, IN, and both graduated from Madison Heights High School. In their spare time, they love to golf, weight lift, box, practice martial arts, boat and enjoy the beach. Dave attended East 91st Christian Church in Indianapolis and Jeff attends Holy Spirit Catholic Church in Indianapolis.

Store Highlights

  • 28-foot walk-in humidor

  • 40 feet of cigar filled humidor cabinets

  • 36 High Back Leather Chairs

  • Entire cabinet of Padron cigars

  • Large selection of pipes & tobacco

  • Private cigar lockers available for rent

  • Humidors - 50 different styles

  • Cigar and pipe accessories

  • Cigar lounge with 65 inch HDTV

  • Free Wi-Fi

  • 3 addtional flat screen TV's

Our Team

Jeff Carmack

Jeff Carmack, Owner

Eddie Cummins

Eddie Cummins

Duane Julius

Duane Julius

Scott Curry

Scott Curry

Upcoming Events!

February 1, 2020
Nat Sherman Cigars
Click here for details!

Download the Cigar Dojo App

This app notifies you of upcoming events including events at Carmack's Cigar Shop, where to smoke, reviews and pictures of cigar smokers!

cigar dojo

Carmack's Twitter Feed

carmackscigars KnobCreek Bourbon and LaGloria Cubana “R” Series Cigars Event on Saturday August 15th, 10-4pm..$2 off KnobCreek dri… https://t.co/rWrrR4VTew
carmackscigars Come to Our Next Awesome Event- La Gloria Cubana R Series & Knob Creek - August 15 from 12-4pm!… https://t.co/SAQl6eQhu5
carmackscigars The party has begun with the shot ski!! My Father Cigar event, and free samples of whiskeys today until 4pm..… https://t.co/kegrT8IlXZ
carmackscigars TODAY IS THE DAY! It's Our Grand Opening with My Father Cigars! https://t.co/tfPakmWmP3 https://t.co/HIfZJV3MiO
carmackscigars One More Day Until Our Grand Opening with My Father Cigars! https://t.co/MTQcbbE2Pz https://t.co/NV9q67J2x5
carmackscigars Two days until Our Grand Opening with My Father Cigars! https://t.co/Fc0ZkOJBg0 https://t.co/h6yL74QiFc

Carmack's Facebook Feed

Carmack's Newsletter Signup

Go to top